All reviews

Mystery

20 games reviewed, ranked by score.

Servant of the Lake

Servant of the Lake

Dark family secrets, perfectly served.

91
lily's world XD

lily's world XD

A chilling mystery, told one browser tab at a time

87
Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy

Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy

Sophia's solo voyage is a stunner, even without the rats

87
The Mermaid Mask

The Mermaid Mask

Submarine murder that outsolves everything the series has done

86
The Incident at Galley House

The Incident at Galley House

A period whodunit with a playback machine that grips

85
Silver Pines

Silver Pines

An unforgettable mystery wrapped in rotoscoped dread.

83
Onimusha: Way of the Sword

Onimusha: Way of the Sword

A glorious blade that deserves a sharper foe

82
Database Detective: Minor Crimes Division

Database Detective: Minor Crimes Division

SQL detective work that turns queries into real deduction

80
Desktop Explorer

Desktop Explorer

A dead PC's files hide a mystery worth cracking

80
Life is Strange - Episode 1

Life is Strange - Episode 1

Time-rewinding teen drama that earns its tears

80
The Wolf Among Us

The Wolf Among Us

Telltale's Noir Fairy Tale Still Lands a Punch

80
Stray

Stray

Being a cat is enough. The rest is window dressing.

78
Crushed In Time

Crushed In Time

Inventive pull-and-stretch puzzles, dulled by guesswork and stray QTEs

77
Welcome to Elderfield

Welcome to Elderfield

A town of charming dread, buried under endless chores.

77
Deer & Boy

Deer & Boy

A wordless journey of grief, tripped by loose controls

76
Orb of Creation

Orb of Creation

An active incremental with real choices, then the updates stopped

76
Big Walk

Big Walk

A tender co-op wander, if the audio mixer relents

74
Sol Cesto

Sol Cesto

Gorgeous grotesque odds-juggling, tripped up by unfair dice and no save

74
Hell Maiden

Hell Maiden

Gorgeous descent into Hell, tripped by run-ending crashes

72
Dimhaven - The Lost Source

Dimhaven - The Lost Source

Sharp logic puzzles, saves that vanish on update

71